Bragg Underground
heart and soul of our Fort Bragg community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Bragg Yard Sales! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

Fayetteville teacher over step her place???

who's talking here?

gloria 2
Kristylin 4
just me 1
Angie 1
Sneez 2
TRISHA 2
JMunderscore 1
Jessica 1
Lori 1
Jen 3
mywarriorswife 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

gloria --- 18 years ago -

Looks like the little army girl was about to cry. This teach way over stepped!! 

gloria --- 18 years ago -

Cumberland Co. School Super issues statement, click to read. My kids don't go to school there...but if they did I'd be sure and contact the school board and attend the next meeting. 

Kristylin --- 18 years ago -

I seen this in the paper, I was very upset by the teacher and what she had to say. We all voted for someone and either who we voted for won or did not we still need to support who did. I just hope the right measures are followed for this teacher and the military families she has casued pain/hurt upon. 

Angie --- 18 years ago -

Politics do not belong in the classroom, especially children of that age. Children are in school to learn and not in school to justify who their parents are voting for during an election. Hopefully this teacher will be disciplined regarding her inappropriate behavior. Just my opinion. 

JMunderscore --- 18 years ago -

Did she really tell that girl that John McCains plan means her Daddy will be in the military another 100 years? Wtf. There is no timeframe for when Obama is going to "end" the war..... This teacher was pushing those kids to far and calling out any kid who didn't have her same views 

TRISHA --- 18 years ago -

Ok I am not defending this teacher at all so don't get me wrong. I am not trying to start a fight but I want everyone to get a teachers opinion on the matter. Also, I have heard that this tape was edited. As a teacher let me just make a comment about parents. We are so ready to say what a horrible person she is for this but we need to look at our actions as well, and I include myself in this comment. We at home talked a lot about this historic election and our kids were right there listening to every word that we said. The day after the election my room was crazy with children going on about how "Obama was going to make all of the military poor and how he doesn't respect our country because he didn't put his hand over his heart" I even had one student interrupt a story to announce that "his mom said that Obama was going to get shot." We don't know what was going on in her class or why she said some of the things she did. Was she wrong to exaggerate, yes but should the price be her job, No. I'm sure most parents have said something to their kids at one time that they wish they could take back but what are we going to do fire you as a parent? Also about the comment that the election had no place in the classroom. Actually North carolina standard course of study says that it does. Events and Holidays are included on what to teach for social studies and I consider this an event. Also how many of you let your kids stay up to watch some of the reports. I know I did because it will be history some day that I want my son to remember. 

Sneez --- 18 years ago -

It also helps if we look at more than just what they show in the clip. When they showed it on the news, they showed a bit more than just the clip including where the Swedish journalist told her to discuss this out of the blue. They also showed the girl talking about how thd discussion had begun to make her think about her Dad and she looked like she wanted to cry only because she was missing him right then and wasn't even thinking about what she was saying. I think we all know how much stuff gets edited out of these things, and we should never take such clips at face value. 

Lori --- 18 years ago -

Wow, I never saw this until now. I think that school needs to rethink this woman's position as an educator. She seemed almost hostile toward the kids who showed support for John McCain. This is terrible. She needs to maintain a neutral position because you have to respect all of the children's views. It is better not brought up. I substitute and we talked about the the importance of voting but when it started to sway into who was voting for who, I had to bring their attention back to our subject. She should have never done this to these kids. 

just me --- 18 years ago -

i think that some of you are over reacting the girls own parents think that the teachers comments were taken the wronge way. 

Jessica --- 18 years ago -

think that some of you are over reacting the girls own parents think that the teachers comments were taken the wronge way. No what she said was wrong i dont care how you look at it...how mean is it to make a child think that if she votes for a person her daddy will be gone forever? Mentally children dont need to hear crap like that. Politics dont belong in the classroom and the teaching staff is NON JUDGEMENTAL!!! Public school systems are all supposed to be non judgemental. If we wanted someones opinions on that crap we would send our children to private school ...Honestly she should be fired for that little comment....how dare someone scare a baby like that especially when she is in a position that she is viewed as a role model in. Tisk tisk xo Jessica 

Jen --- 18 years ago -

Ohhh, I just found this discussion board! How cool is this? Anyways, in regards to this thread...As a parent of a child who attended this school I am disgusted beyond belief. To be very honest, I am not suprised in the least that it came from this teacher. I served on the PTO for two years while my son attended elementary school there and this teacher has a reputation. To give a little more in depth look into her philosophy of teaching, all you have to do is take a look at the makeup of her current class. She requested only African American children in her class and that is exactly what she got! I think it is horrible that this day in age a teacher actually requested a segregated class and was given one. Way to keep a classroom diverse. I have written the superintendent of Cumberland County Schools to express my outrage over the video (which parents were never informed that their children would be participating in) as well as her segregated class. I suggest anyone who feels the same to do likewise. Even if your child doesn't go to Mary McCarthur, we have to send a message that this cannot be allowed at ANY school! 

mywarriorswife --- 18 years ago -

The #@&#%@^# should be canned - no ifs ands or buts!! How dare she attack a Military Child and furthermore not even chid the Obama supporter on his clear lack of information regarding any issues. It'd due to the large Military presence that Fayetteville gets the property taxes that pay for this woman's job and w/o it I am sure there would be far less school teachers employed in the Fayetteville area. But yet I am sure she'll pull the minority card, only receive a tiny peck on the wrist and continue to be allowed to be employed around Military Children and no doubt she'll go right on trashing them and their parents. Beleive you me if this were my child there would have been a picket formed at 6am the next day at that school, with EVERY single form of media called to attend, demanding her resignation and I would set up camp there to get it accomplished. How disgusting!!! And this is what we pay taxes for? This is how our children are educated while we are busy defending these peoples rights to run at the mouth when ever and where ever? I'll bet she would have been a proud draft dodger given the chance!!! 

TRISHA --- 17 years ago -

Wow you guys are starting to get way to heated. Just looking at this clip and judging. (not counting the parent from the school) Let me ask if it was all that bad don't you think the childs parent would have been mad? As I hear they are fine with it. Maybe they know something that we don't. Also let me say I am really glad I am not your childs teacher. Trust me we don't do it for the money I know I make less than an E-1 and still owe money on my schooling. We do it to help kids and all we get in return is parents complaning every day and worring that one lesson could lead us to the unemployment office. How would you like to have to every day watch every step you make because there are angry parents like you that need a little excitment in their life so hey lets go pick on a teacher today. Yet those same parents are swearing or smoking or something in front of their kids. Hey she might play the race act but you are playing the military one. Just because you are military does not make your kids any more special then the other kids and don't start bashing me becasue I am also a proud army wife but I don't expect my child to get any special treatment for it. That money we get for serving army children you really think it is enough to pay teachers? Wow. Go sit in on your child's class for one whole day and admit that you could teach children everyday and be perfect at it and then maybe you will have a right to pickett in front of the school. Basically what I am saying is walk a day in their shoes before judging. 

Jen --- 17 years ago -

Just because you are military does not make your kids any more special then the other kids and don't start bashing me becasue I am also a proud army wife but I don't expect my child to get any special treatment for it Not special treatment, just plain ole decent consideration! I cannot fathom a teacher looking at a child and telling them that McCain wants to keep her daddy in Iraq for 100 years. That wasn't political, it was a personal comment that was used as a fear tactic on an elementary school child. I don't expect a teacher to be perfect and never make a mistake. Heck, we all say things we wish we could take back as soon as it leaves our mouth. The problem is that this teacher doesn't think she did anything wrong. That is what is MOST disturbing to me. Teachers need to temper their thoughts and words with respect to who their audience is. This teacher doesn't think she has to do that, and that is a shame for any child that is in her classroom. 

Sneez --- 17 years ago -

I don't expect a teacher to be perfect and never make a mistake. Heck, we all say things we wish we could take back as soon as it leaves our mouth. The problem is that this teacher doesn't think she did anything wrong. That is one thing I disagree with. She did the same thing we all have been known to do and said something she had heard (in a speech no less) before thinking and wished she could take it back. If you check out abc channel 11's piece on this story you will see that the family is indeed taking this all in stride while the teacher herself was constantly crying because the last thing she ever wanted to do was say something hurtful to a child. 

Jen --- 17 years ago -

That is one thing I disagree with. She did the same thing we all have been known to do and said something she had heard (in a speech no less) before thinking and wished she could take it back. If you check out abc channel 11's piece on this story you will see that the family is indeed taking this all in stride while the teacher herself was constantly crying because the last thing she ever wanted to do was say something hurtful to a child. Eh, maybe I am jaded because I already know her "teaching" skills. Her reputation proceeds her (for me) so it is harder for me to give her the benefit of the doubt. Maybe if it was just this one incident I could, but coupled with other things it seems to be more of a pattern that a Fruedian slip. I have to say that just because she heard something in a speech on the television, doesn't mean it is appropriate for her to say to her class of 10 year olds. I see and hear TONS of stuff that is entirely NOT age appropriate on the local news. Oh, and the crying, eh, again I am biased from what I already know about her. I think it was more of crying because what she got herself into. If she couldn't see the look on that childs face when she said it, that is proof enough she shouldn't be teaching. 

Kristylin --- 17 years ago -

Teacher gets reprimand for classroom remarks By Francis X. Gilpin Staff writer ADVERTISEMENT -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- RELATED 2nd teacher under fire for classroom politics (Nov. 13) Parents of girl in YouTube video defend teacher (Nov. 10) Fayetteville teacher says video clip doctored (Nov. 8) -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- A Fayetteville teacher whose classroom encounter with a young John McCain supporter created a stir on YouTube has confirmed that she was given a disciplinary letter. But Diatha Harris said an internal investigation of her conduct cleared the veteran educator of violating state law or Cumberland County Board of Education policy. Harris, 53, was videotaped in the spring by a Swedish film crew, leading a classroom discussion about the 2008 presidential election with fifth-graders at Mary McArthur Elementary School. During the discussion, Harris called the Iraq war “senseless” and told her pupils that U.S. troops could stay in Iraq for 100 years if McCain was president. “So that means that your daddy could stay in the military for another hundred years,” Harris told pupil Cathy Thompson in the classroom footage. In other scenes shot outside the classroom, Harris sports a Barack Obama campaign button. The video aired in a documentary broadcast on Finnish television earlier this month. A blogger posted snippets from the broadcast on YouTube, and Internet viewers responded by bombarding Superintendent Bill Harrison’s office with calls for Harris to be fired. Harris has apologized to the pupil and her parents, Army Staff Sgt. Robert Thompson and Angela Moore. But the parents have said they didn’t object to how Harris handled herself in the classroom. In interviews this week, Harris downplayed the significance of the written reprimand from Harrison. She has not made the letter public. “But I do want it out there that I did not break any board policy,” Harris said. “I did not break any laws.” Harris remains a teacher at the school. School officials were unavailable for comment at their offices Friday. Harrison couldn’t be reached. But the superintendent has said that no information about possible discipline of Harris would be made public because of state personnel laws. Harris, who has taught for 31 years, said she didn’t want to make additional public statements until she consults with her lawyer. School officials also are withholding information about possible discipline of another local teacher. Melissa Smith was accused of disparaging an Obama administration in front of her Mac Williams Middle School class after the election. In a complaint to the school system, a parent quoted Smith as telling the pupils “don’t come crying to me” if the taxes paid by their parents go to “a 13-year-old girl for an abortion.” Smith later apologized to her class after the complaint was made, according to the parent. Staff writer Francis X. Gilpin can be reached at gilpinf@fayobserver.com or 323-4848, ext. 372. Keep up to date with all the news! Try our TxtAlerts, Fayobserver.com mobile edition, and our PM Newscast every weekday at 3:00. To subscribe to The Fayetteville Observer, click here. 

mywarriorswife --- 17 years ago -

Go sit in on your child's class for one whole day and admit that you could teach children everyday and be perfect at it and then maybe you will have a right to pickett in front of the school. Basically what I am saying is walk a day in their shoes before judging. Honey, this is why I homeschool my kids. Military kids go through enough in their lives, they don't need this #$%^ from the person who is supposedly providing them with an education. Oh and by the way, the tears were all an act for the media, I can guarentee that. After all, if she really was so distressed over this comment, she should have been at the parents front door the next day with the tears not months later when she was caught on tape and her job is at stake. Clearly the almighty BUCK is her only concern, not the well being of any child in that classroom. And a final note - why didn't she lay into the Obama supporter and make any 'media induced' comments regarding him and his campaign? HHHMMMMMMMM 

Kristylin --- 17 years ago -

Teacher says talk violated school rules A staff report ADVERTISEMENT Fayetteville teacher Diatha Harris is now acknowledging that she was found to have violated a Cumberland County school policy in connection with a controversial YouTube video. Last month, Harris said she was reprimanded after a Swedish film crew taped her leading a classroom discussion about the 2008 presidential election with fifth-graders at Mary McArthur Elementary School. During the discussion, Harris called the Iraq war “senseless” and told pupils that U.S. troops could stay in Iraq for 100 years if John McCain was president. “So that means that your daddy could stay in the military for another hundred years,” Harris told a pupil in the classroom footage. An administrative investigation cleared her of violating state law, according to Harris. But Harris said Monday the probe did find she broke school board policy, contrary to what she said after getting a reprimand letter in November. School officials consider the letter private under state law. Harris, 53, said the policy she is accused of violating addresses political activity in schools. 

Kristylin --- 17 years ago -

Honey, this is why I homeschool my kids. Military kids go through enough in their lives, they don't need this #$%^ from the person who is supposedly providing them with an education. My mom homeschooled us for these reason as well!! Im happy to see there are some out there. ;o) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children
parenting
politics

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Bragg Underground